 Hyperion Shield#10367 · Armor | 65 | 60 | Shield | Uncommon |
 Hyperion Pauldrons#10390 · Armor | 63 | 58 | Shoulder | Uncommon |
 Hyperion Gauntlets#10386 · Armor | 62 | 57 | Hands | Uncommon |
 Hyperion Vambraces#10391 · Armor | 60 | 55 | Wrists | Uncommon |
 Hyper-Radiant Flame Reflector#18638 · Armor | 58 | 53 | Trinket | Rare |
 ICECROWN TEST GOD BP#40481 · Armor | 252 | 70 | Chest | Epic |
 Ick's Rotting Thumb#50235 · Armor | 232 | 80 | Trinket | Epic |
 Idol of the Flourishing Life#46138 · Armor | 226 | 80 | Relic | Epic |
 Idol of the Plainstalker#37573 · Armor | 138 | — | Relic | Uncommon |
 Ikeyen's Pauldrons#25514 · Armor | 87 | — | Shoulder | Uncommon |
 Ikeyen's Boots#25516 · Armor | 87 | — | Feet | Uncommon |
 Ikfirus's Sack of Wonder#50001 · Armor | 264 | 80 | Chest | Epic |
| Ikfirus's Sack of Wonder#50656 · Armor | 277 | 80 | Chest | Epic |
 Blind-Seers Icon#32361 · Armor | 141 | 70 | Held in off-hand | Epic |
 Icon of the Silver Crescent#29370 · Armor | 110 | 70 | Trinket | Epic |
 Icon of Unyielding Courage#28121 · Armor | 115 | 70 | Trinket | Rare |
 Illidari Bracers#31224 · Armor | 103 | 66 | Wrists | Rare |
 Illidari Bindings#31225 · Armor | 103 | 66 | Wrists | Rare |
| Illidari Wristguards#31223 · Armor | 103 | 66 | Wrists | Rare |
 Illidari Cloak#31201 · Armor | 103 | 66 | Back | Rare |
 Illidari Vambraces#31221 · Armor | 103 | 66 | Wrists | Rare |
 Illskar's Greatcloak#43924 · Armor | 174 | — | Back | Uncommon |
| Phantasmal Cloak#18689 · Armor | 62 | 57 | Back | Rare |
 Illustration of the Dragon Soul#40432 · Armor | 213 | 80 | Trinket | Epic |
 Core Forged Greaves#18806 · Armor | 70 | 60 | Feet | Epic |
 Sea Rusted Gauntlets#38087 · Armor | 146 | — | Hands | Uncommon |
 Everbloom Idol#29390 · Armor | 110 | 70 | Relic | Epic |
 Evergreen Gloves#7738 · Armor | 18 | — | Hands | Uncommon |
 Evergreen Branch#36465 · Armor | 154 | 73 | Held in off-hand | Uncommon |
 Eversong Cuffs#34602 · Armor | 115 | 70 | Wrists | Epic |