 Potent Pants#15176 · Armor | 50 | 45 | Legs | Uncommon |
 Potent Gloves#15174 · Armor | 50 | 45 | Hands | Uncommon |
 Potent Bands#15172 · Armor | 47 | 42 | Wrists | Uncommon |
 New Age Painting#45981 · Miscellaneous | 80 | — | No equipment slot | Poor |
 Porcelain Bell#45977 · Miscellaneous | 70 | — | No equipment slot | Poor |
 Portals Deck#19277 · Quest items | 60 | — | No equipment slot | Epic |
 Ace of Portals#19276 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
| Eight of Portals#19284 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
| Seven of Portals#19283 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
| Six of Portals#19282 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
| Five of Portals#19281 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
| Four of Portals#19280 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
| Three of Portals#19279 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
| Two of Portals#19278 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Rare |
 Poobah's Nose Ring#4118 · Armor | 50 | — | Wrists | Uncommon |
 Pontiff's Pantaloons of Prophecy#28218 · Armor | 115 | 70 | Legs | Rare |
 Pontifex Kilt#30543 · Armor | 110 | 70 | Legs | Epic |
 Jaded Crystal Dagger#34604 · Weapons | 115 | 70 | Main hand | Epic |
 Polychromatic Visionwrap#12609 · Armor | 61 | 56 | Chest | Rare |
 Pads of the Dread Wolf#13210 · Armor | 60 | 55 | Feet | Rare |
 Prospector's Pads#14566 · Armor | 25 | 20 | Shoulder | Uncommon |
 Pads of the Venom Spider#13103 · Armor | 38 | 33 | Shoulder | Rare |
 Bloodspore Moth Pollen#34976 · Quest items | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Common |
 Piece of Polished Driftwood#34839 · Miscellaneous | 1 | — | No equipment slot | Poor |
 Polished Dragonslayer's Signet#49313 · Armor | 232 | — | Finger | Epic |
| Polished Dragonslayer's Signet#49486 · Armor | 245 | — | Finger | Epic |
 Polished Zombie Exterminator#44393 · Weapons | 174 | — | Ranged | Rare |
 Polished Walking Staff#16889 · Weapons | 24 | — | Two-hand | Uncommon |
 Polished Mirror Helm#49804 · Armor | 219 | 80 | Head | Epic |
 Polished Scale Belt#2148 · Armor | 27 | 22 | Waist | Common |